By SPJ Adjusting Services | Insurance Appraisals
Windstorm in Texas Insurance: When bad weather hits North Texas, clients will find themselves in a maze of insurance terms before repair work has a chance to begin.
When insurers apply higher deductibles, the real dispute becomes whether is a Windstorm in Texas insurance policies actually define or merely assume.
One of the most confusing areas with which we regularly come into contact at SPJ Adjusting regards how insurance companies categorize storm occurrences, particularly tornadoes.
Typically, most property policies in Dallas and across Texas have “windstorm” deductibles, but very few, if any, have a definition of a “windstorm.” The consequence of this lack of definition can become a very big problem in a loss instance where a tornado occurred, and in this case, a carrier contends a tornado activates a “windstorm” deductible.
The central question will thus be:
Is a Tornado a Windstorm in Texas Insurance Policy?
A brief look at current Texas case law and a lengthy look at SPJ Adjusting’s years of adjusting experience concerning tornado damage claims in cities such as Dallas, Lubbock, and Houston, shows this to be far from true.
This piece will examine the matter from a Texas + Dallas point of view and describe why this definition is important, as well as how SPJ Adjusting can assist clients with such claims through public adjusting, insurance appraisal, and umpire assistance.
Why Definition of “Windstorm” is Important in Dallas Cases
A common Texas standard is to have a much higher deductible for losses due to either a wind storm or a loss due to hail than an all peril deductible. The difference can run into tens of thousands of dollars for many homeowners in Dallas, particularly in high-end neighborhoods such as Lakewood, Preston Hollow, and North Dallas.
Figure:
A $600,000 home in the Dallas area may support:
“All perils deductible:
Windstorm/Hail Deductible:
And, if a tornado strikes this residence and the insurance company declares this a “windstorm,” this deductible charge immediately rises from $2,500 to $12,000.
The disputed amount of $9,500 is where all attention is focused.
Given the fact that Texas is a leading state in terms of tornado occurrences in the country, this topic can never be considered uncommon.
How Tornados are considered in Windstorm in Texas Insurance
A Texas state-wide statute defining “windstorm” is not enforced in Texas. A tornado in Dallas is contingent upon:
How the policy is written, and
Whether the judge holds the word to be ambiguous, if it is not defined.
SPJ Adjusting views countless policies each year in Texas and finds the same problem existing in each case:
In most cases, “windstorm” is not defined in these policies.
In an instance where a term in a contract is not defined in a case in Texas, a set of rules is used in interpreting
A word is considered ambiguous if it may be interpreted in more than one way.
Omissions or deductions which present an ambiguity will be interpreted in a manner beneficial to the-insured.
The presence of rival definitions which are reasonable is sufficient to establish ambiguity.
However, if it is ambiguous, then it is not possible to enforce the deductible wished for by the insurance company.
Such rules are important because insurance companies frequently operate under the doctrine “strong winds = windstorm,” but meteorology does not correlate this way.
Are Tornados and Windstorms the Same? Dallas Meteorology Disagrees
The local meteorology community in North Texas makes a distinct split concerning:
- Tornadoes classify under a distinct type of weather
How to
“Windstorm Warnings” are issued by Dallas County, but not “T
Meteorologists define tornados as “rotating, violent columns of air” and distinguish them from events involving straight-line winds. - The Public Understands the Difference
The local news sometimes reports straight line wind occurrences as windstorms, but WFAA, FOX 4, and The Dallas Morning News report them consistently, and the tornados as an outbreak. - Differences in measurement systems exist
Tornadoes: measured using rotational damage from winds on the Enhanced Fujita Scale.
Windstorms: measured in terms of sustained or gust windspeed, without rotation.
Such differences have significance in court because they reinforce the point that the average homeowner in the city of Dallas would not relate a tornado to an ordinary wind storm.
These distinctions reinforce arguments that is a Windstorm in Texas insurance classification is not as clear-cut as insurers claim.
A Texas Appeal Court speaks up, and this is important for homeowners in Dallas.
“A recent Texas appellate case, which will not be quoted here, holds:”
Windstorms can have a different meaning in a policy without a definition.
One can, in fact, classify a tornado not as a wind storm.
As the ambiguities in an insurance contract are interpreted in favor of the insured, the windstorm deductible did not apply.
Such advice is very helpful for people in Dallas because it is a common occurrence to have been affected by a tornado, yet a higher deductible is always used by these companies without being given a good reason.
What this all Means for your Dallas Claim
“If your home in the Dallas area, including Richardson, Garland, Rowlett, Irving, Lancaster, and other parts of the city, has been affected by a tornado, you may not owe your homeowners insurance deductible if:
Your policy fails to define “windstorm,” and Your claim relates to damage by a tornado.
SPJ Adjusting have successfully challenged incorrect deductible decisions in cases involving Texas homeowners for:
Tornado losses
Hail/Wind
Classification of straight-line winds and tornados:
Slab level winds
First Claim
Disputes over definition of storm in appraisal/umpire actions
How SPJ Adjusting Fights for Policyholders in Dallas
- Public Adjusting for Tornado Damage
While representing Dallas policyholders, we make a case to record damage to buildings, roofs, interiors, and mechanics in case of a tornado or a wind storm. - Insurance Appraisal Advocacy
In case your carrier underestimates or wrongly categorizes a storm, your rights will be protected during the appraisal procedure.
- Certified Umpire Services
SPJ offers impartial and very experienced umpire assistance in Texas cases where a disagreement among appraisers arises in connection with the application of tornado or windstorm principles. - Deductible Classification Reviews
As part of our evaluation of your policy, we will assess if your insurance provider’s deductible selection is within the bounds of state law in Texas. - Local Insight Across Dallas
Based on both the 2019 tornado in the Dallas area and the series of windstorms in North Texas during 2023-2024, we are aware of how the local insurance companies are handling these claims and of how to contest these inaccurate assumptions.
Tips for Policyholders in Dallas After a Tornado
– Record debris patterns
Patterns of debris transport during rotation can be used for classifying tornados
– Save local news coverage
Agreed. It’s a tornado if the news media says so, which lends credibility to your definition.
– Request meteorology information from the insurer
Often, carriers employ generalized charts of wind, which do not discriminate in terms of tornado activity.
– Get an independent inspection Carriers will frequently overlook damage from uplift, ripped shingle seams, and shifts in structure because of tornados.
Do not accept the deductible classification at face value “If it’s not in your policy, you have leverage,”
Conclusion
Residents in Dallas have a right to honest answers, fair treatment, and a claims process based on both the science and the law. A tornado in itself will not be considered a Windstorm in Texas Insurance law, and in such circumstances where a definition is not present, Texas law will favor a construction in favor of the policyholder. SPJ Adjusting is available to help make sure this does not happen in Dallas families.
When policies are silent, courts often side with homeowners challenging whether is a Windstorm in Texas insurance companies insist upon.
CALL TO ACTION
Covering all of the United States with Insurance Appraisal and Umpire Services
